Spot of Parchment, June 2019 - The Burning of the White House
But what happened after that? The British fire destroyed almost everything in the original White House. Rain started later that evening, which prevented the fire from spreading beyond the grounds of the house, but it didn’t save the shell of the home as originally reported. Instead, the hot temperatures combined with the water caused the stones to expand and contract quickly, producing many dangerous cracks. The White House was essentially rubble.
In October, Congress voted to appropriate the funds to rebuild the White House. The legislation squeaked by with a slim majority and Monroe wasted no time starting construction. He and Hoban agreed that the exterior shell of the White House had to remain in place, lest Congress change its mind about the location. Over the next several years, Hoban and his crew of both free and enslaved laborers rebuilt the White House from the inside out. He kept the same floor plan, but added the North Portico to provide coverage for arriving visitors. In 1824, he added the South Portico at Monroe’s request. It was the last project he completed before he died the next year.
I’ve focused on presidential precedents in my work for a very long time—the cabinet is one big jumble of precedents and Washington set about a billion while in office. But I found the story of the rebuild of the White House to be really interesting because it challenges our notions of what precedents can be, who decides which ones are important, and when they are recognized. From a shockingly early date, presidents, and Americans more broadly appreciated the symbolic value of the White House. The history of the space, who had lived in it, and what had come before him were so important to Monroe that he saved the stones. They were really just a pile of rocks, but when put together and painted, they meant a whole lot more.